| Franchise |
QB | RB | WR | TE | PK | Def |
| LO08 | Favre, B Pennington, C | Faulk, K Johnson, L McFadden, D Morris, M | Ginn Jr., T Johnson, A Porter, J Smith, S Ward, H | Miller, H Miller, Z | Lindell, R | Buccaneers, T Eagles, P |
| Black 13 | Manning, E Roethlisberger, B | Alexander, S Barber, M Green, A Jones-Drew, M Young, S | Harrison, M Hill, J Holmes, S Randle El, A Toomer, A | Crumpler, A Gates, A | Crosby, M | Steelers, P |
| mellow | Garrard, D Rodgers, A | Dunn, W Green-Ellis, B Hillis, P Washington, L | Evans, L Moss, R Muhammad, M Wayne, R | Lewis, M Olsen, G Stevens, J | Kaeding, N | Bills, B Dolphins, M |
| N E Bobblehead | Romo, T Rosenfels, S | Jones, F Jones, J Smith, K Tomlinson, L | Coles, L Edwards, B Galloway, J Gonzalez, A | Davis, V Spaeth, M Winslow, K | Folk, N | Jaguars, J Patriots, N |
| MAINEEAST | Campbell, J Rivers, P | Hightower, T Jacobs, B Johnson, C Peterson, A | Chambers, C Hixon, D Houshmandzadeh, T Moore, L Royal, E Williams, R | Scaife, B | Bironas, R Rackers, N | Raiders, O |
| A-Town Ligers | Cassel, M Thigpen, T | Forte, M Lewis, J Slaton, S | Breaston, S Camarillo, G Colston, M Jenkins, M Moss, S | Graham, D Witten, J | Bryant, M Elam, J | Titans, T Vikings, M |
| IM | Garcia, J Warner, K | Benson, C Fargas, J Jackson, S Jones, T | Avery, D Bess, D Bowe, D Bruce, I Holt, T Marshall, B | Boss, K Cooley, C | Scobee, J | Ravens, B |
| Lightnin' Strikes | Cutler, J Delhomme, J | Betts, L Portis, C Stewart, J Turner, M Williams, D | Branch, D Driver, D Johnson, C Owens, T | Gonzalez, T Keller, D | Longwell, R | Colts, I Packers, G |
| rozie | Orton, K Schaub, M | Grant, R Jackson, B Lynch, M Norwood, J | Burress, P Engram, B Lloyd, B Mason, D Ocho Cinco, C | Carlson, J Shockey, J | Gostkowski, S | Chargers, S Cowboys, D |
| Buck Turgidson's Pro Bowlers | Brees, D Ryan, M | Choice, T Foster, D Gore, F Moore, M Morris, S Parker, W | Fitzgerald, L Jackson, D Jennings, G Walter, K | Clark, D | Vinatieri, A | Cardinals, A Jets, N |
| Burners | Manning, P | Addai, J Brown, R Rhodes, D Taylor, C Thomas, P | Berrian, B Boldin, A Gage, J Jackson, V | Miller, B Shiancoe, V | Carney, J Reed, J | Panthers, C Texans, H |
| Warriors | Collins, K McNabb, D | McGahee, W Sproles, D Ward, D Westbrook, B White, L | Bryant, A Cotchery, J Welker, W White, R | Daniels, O Scheffler, T | Kasay, J | Bears, C Giants, N |